Is my card worth grading?

Grade a card when the realistic graded price, minus grading and shipping fees, comfortably beats what the raw card sells for today. For most cards that means a raw value above roughly $50, plus a surface and centering good enough to have a real shot at a 9 or 10.

Updated 2026-08-26

The break-even calculation

Work it out before you send anything. Take the price the card fetches raw. Take the price it fetches in the grade you honestly expect, not the grade you hope for. Subtract the grading fee and shipping both ways. If what is left does not clearly beat the raw price, keep the card raw.

A worked example. A card sells raw at $60. In a PSA 9 it sells at $110, in a PSA 10 at $400. Grading and shipping cost about $35. At a 9 you clear $75 against $60 raw, which is barely worth the three-month wait. At a 10 you clear $365. So the entire decision rests on whether the card can realistically hit a 10.

Check these four things before you decide

Graders penalise the same handful of flaws. Inspect for them under a bright light, holding the card at an angle.

• Centering: look at the border width on opposing sides. Anything past roughly 60/40 caps most cards at a 9.
• Corners: whitening on a corner is visible to the naked eye and is the most common reason for an 8.
• Edges: run your eye along the back edges. Nicks and whitening from pack fresh handling are common.
• Surface: tilt the card into the light. Print lines, scratches, and dimples on foil are what separate a 9 from a 10.

Modern chase cards versus vintage

On modern cards, print quality is high and 10s are relatively common, so the premium for a 10 is what makes grading worthwhile. If your copy has any visible flaw, the odds of a 10 drop sharply and so does the case for grading.

On vintage, high grades are scarce because the cards have been handled for twenty-five years. A vintage card in a 7 or 8 can still carry a strong premium over raw, because buyers want authentication as much as condition.

Bulk submissions change the maths

Grading companies price by tier, and the cheapest tiers require minimum quantities. If you have twenty cards worth grading, the per-card cost drops and cards in the $30 to $50 range start to make sense.

One card on its own at a fast turnaround tier rarely does.

Common questions

How long does grading take?

It varies by company and service tier, from a few weeks at the expensive end to several months on economy tiers. Factor the wait into the decision, because prices move while your card sits in a queue.

Does a low grade hurt the card's value?

A card that grades 6 or 7 is usually worth less than it was raw, because the slab removes the buyer's hope that it might have been a 9. Only send cards you expect to grade well.

Related guides